Home United States New York Italian restaurants Trastevere Italian restaurants

Trastevere

4.4 230 reviews 1391 Coney Island Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11230, United States

Discover this place

Trastevere, located at 1391 Coney Island Ave, Brooklyn, NY, is a delightful Italian restaurant that captures the essence of old-world charm while offering a diverse and delectable menu. Patrons rave about the exquisite flavors that permeate every dish, reflecting an admirable commitment to Italian culinary traditions. Reviewers highlight standout offerings such as the risotto alla bolognese, which one customer described as “out of this world.” The chicken dishes—ranging from Chicken Marsala to Chicken Trastevere—are consistently praised for their rich flavors and perfect preparation. The emphasis on lighter meals ensures diners leave satisfied but not overly stuffed, a refreshing approach in today’s dining landscape. The ambiance is also a vital aspect of the experience. With beautifully crafted decor and dim lighting, it serves as an ideal setting for romantic dinners and group gatherings alike. The attentive service further enhances the meal, making each visit memorable. Desserts, particularly the house-made Napoleone Cream, receive accolades for their delightful sweetness and presentation. Overall, the combination of great food, charming atmosphere, and excellent service makes Trastevere a must-visit destination in Brooklyn for Italian cuisine lovers.

Photos

Trastevere - Photo 1 Trastevere - Photo 2 Trastevere - Photo 3 Trastevere - Photo 4 Trastevere - Photo 5 Trastevere - Photo 6 Trastevere - Photo 7 Trastevere - Photo 8

Amenities & More

Service options

  • Curbside pickup
  • Delivery
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in

Dining options

  • Dinner
  • Dessert

Amenities

  • Bar onsite
  • Restroom

Crowd

  • Family-friendly
Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Trastevere before visiting.

Reviews for Trastevere

4.4
230 reviews
5
100%
4
23%
3
9%
2
2%
1
9%

Review highlights

Based on 230 reviews

Trastevere is widely praised for its authentic Italian and kosher cuisine, particularly its standout pasta dishes and expertly prepared meats such as veal and lamb. Diners frequently highlight the restaurant’s elegant atmosphere, blending old-world charm with modern décor, creating a memorable dining experience. Service quality is consistently recognized as attentive and professional. While some note that pricing leans toward the higher end, guests generally agree the quality and flavor justify the cost. The menu offers a balanced variety that avoids heaviness, appealing to those seeking a refined yet approachable meal in Brooklyn. Overall, Trastevere is regarded as a reliable destination for quality Italian dining with a unique and inviting ambiance.

Eliezer Graber
May 06, 2025

Everything at Trastevere was delicious. We've been here a few times now and haven't been disappointed. The risotto alla bolognese is out of this world.

Judy Welwart
Apr 03, 2025

A lovely dining experience. Trastevere never fails to please. A restaurant with old world charm and a delicious menu. You can't go wrong everything is great!

Hal Doueck
Apr 02, 2025

Really cool experience in Brooklyn if you're looking for a fancy meat restaurant with a different type of vibe. Decor is beautifully done, and the menu is heavy on the pasta, chicken, lamb and veal. Although they do have a ribeye steak option, this is not a steakhouse. They seem to pride themselves on a lighter style, so you don't feel terribly stuffed when you leave. This restaurant is located in the spot where the old Cafe Venezia used to be, and is fairly large, complete with a second floor equipped with some very large tables for big groups. The menu is a play on the old Tevere restaurant which existed on the upper east side in Manhattan. The downstairs has dim lighting and is nice for a romantic date. They do serve wine but are waiting for their liquor license for a full bar. Appetizers were great. Highly recommend the fried artichokes, which were both crunchy and juicy with a lemon twist. The truffle risotto was extremely flavorful and I liked that there wasn't so much liquid/cream. The salads are done well, and it's nice that most main courses come with salads, i.e. the breaded veal and lamb chops. I liked the Bolognese and lasagna, they tend to know what they are doing with tomato-based dishes like meatballs as well (although it was weird that it came with a ton of sauce but no spaghetti). The desserts were excellent, the napoleon was really nice and the chocolate fondue was very much liquid though. Remember that these are all non-dairy. All in all, definitely worth checking out!

Jacob Massry
Mar 19, 2025

Beautiful place! Great service and great food. Steak and Veal was amazing! A little pricey but definitely worth it.

Eily Alkada
Mar 18, 2025

Great vibes. Place looks better than the original. Food and desert are top. Service amazing

Elliot Beyda
Mar 18, 2025

Great Italian Kosher food! You have to try the Veal chop and the assorted main platter was amazing!

Jesse Icahn
Mar 06, 2025

I have so much to say about this place I will try to keep it quick and concise. Trastevere hits all the marks- The food is delectable- I especially recommend the beef carpaccio and the Stracotto and they have an extensive wine/spirits collection. It has gorgeous layout, lovely color scheme lots of seating options including private booths. This place has true style and elegance. The wait staff are incredibly polite and swift in delivering the food. I would suggest this place to anyone looking for a relaxing luxurious experience that won’t break the bank. I have been to places twice the price that don’t pale in comparison to the experience I had here.

jak katari
Feb 17, 2025

This is a hidden gem in Brooklyn. Wonderful drinks food and allot of privacy

Write a review

Share your experience with the community. Your honest feedback helps others find great places.

Quick info

Address
1391 Coney Island Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11230, United States
Category
Italian restaurants

Location

Own this business?

Claim this listing to update info, respond to reviews and reach more customers.

Claim listing

Discover more places like this

Browse thousands of bars, restaurants, cafés and more — wherever you go.

View Menu